Makati City, Metro Manila | Dagupan City, Pangasinan
info@fernandezlawoffices.com
+63921-328-2688
Home-> Blogs
Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) vs. 1Accountants Party-List, Inc., et al.
G.R. No. 246027 (En Banc Resolution, January 28, 2025)
Whether the SEC has the authority to require the mandatory accreditation of Certified Public Accountants (CPAs) acting as external auditors for corporations with registered securities or secondary licenses ("covered entities"), or if such a requirement illegally encroaches upon the exclusive authority of the Board of Accountancy (BOA) to regulate the accountancy profession.
The SEC issued Rule 68 of the Implementing Rules and Regulations (IRR) of the Securities Regulation Code (SRC) and SEC Memorandum Circular No. 13, Series of 2009. These regulations required CPAs to obtain specific accreditation from the SEC before they could audit the financial statements of "covered entities."
1Accountants Party-List, et al. challenged the rules, arguing that under the Philippine Accountancy Act of 2004, the regulation of the accountancy profession is vested solely in the BOA. They claimed the SEC acted ultra vires (beyond its powers) by imposing an additional licensing requirement.
Previous Rulings: In a 2022 Decision and a 2023 Resolution, the Supreme Court initially agreed with the respondents, declaring the SEC’s accreditation requirement null and void. The SEC subsequently filed a Second Motion for Reconsideration, arguing its mandate to protect investors and regulate the capital market necessitates this oversight.
The Supreme Court GRANTED the SEC’s Second Motion for Reconsideration, completely REVERSING its previous decisions. The Court reinstated the validity of the SEC's regulations, ruling that the SEC does have the authority to require accreditation for external auditors of covered entities.
Incidental and Implied Powers: Under Sections 5 and 72 of the SRC, the SEC has the express power to "regulate, investigate or supervise the activities of persons" to ensure compliance and protect the capital markets. Because the law does not distinguish between natural and juridical persons, the SEC can regulate individual auditors auditing the financial statements of covered entities.
Accreditation vs. Licensure: The SEC’s accreditation does not usurp the BOA’s licensure process; they are complementary. While the BOA's licensure ensures a CPA meets the minimum statutory standards to practice, the SEC’s accreditation serves as a specific quality assurance mechanism to ensure adherence to international standards required for a highly regulated financial sector.
Not a Blanket Restriction on CPAs: The accreditation requirement does not curtail the general practice of accountancy. The SEC noted that only around 17,000 (less than 3%) of the over 600,000 registered corporations require SEC-accredited auditors. CPAs who choose not to be accredited can still practice their profession and audit the remaining 97% of corporations.
State Policy Takes Precedence: The right of the State to regulate professions for the public good (in this case, protecting investors from fraudulent financial reporting, as seen in past financial scams) takes precedence over a professional's privilege to practice. The existence of the BOA does not preclude other agencies from implementing specific regulatory measures tied to their own mandates.